Markets Call Central Bankers’ Bluff

Despite yesterday’s relief rally, the market appears to be turning on Powell and the Federal Reserve again.

Papa Powell tried to soothe the market with a 75bp rate hike and some smooth talk, but after some time to mull over his message, the market isn’t buying it.

Recession fears are picking up around the globe, with stocks making new cycle lows across many U.S. and international indexes. Risk-off action is occurring simultaneously as many central banks are raising rates at their most aggressive pace in decades to curb record-high inflation. 🥵

In the last few weeks, we’ve seen moves from the U.S. Federal Reserve, Reserve Bank of Australia, the Bank of England, the Swiss National Bank, the Bank of Canada, the Reserve Bank of India, the Central Bank of Argentina, and others…

This great chart from global-rates.com summarizes them all. 📈

Commentary from many of these central bankers suggests that they will fight hard to bring inflation down, even if that means sacrificing some economic growth.

This view contrasts their thoughts from just a few months ago that bringing inflation down while keeping the economy intact was not only possible but probable.

Some say that the unlikeliness of that scenario was telegraphed by the move in government bond markets, which rallied aggressively since January as inflation expectations grew.

That preemptive tightening in the bond market highlights what we all know deep down but don’t want to admit.

Central banks don’t *entirely* control interest rates. Instead, the market controls interest rates, and central banks do their best to use the tools at their disposal to meet their objectives.

And right now, many in the market are calling bullshit on the Fed and other central banks’ idea that inflation will come down without hurting the economy. 

Whether or not the market is correct remains to be seen. However, softening economic data, record pessimism among consumers/business leaders, and big bets from hedge fund titans like Bridgewater are anticipating more pain ahead.

Who do you think is going to be right? Let us know your thoughts! 💭

P.S. we haven’t even talked about the Bank of Japan and the Japanese Government Bond market, but that needs a post of its own. For now, just know that speculators are playing chicken with the central bank, betting that it won’t be able to keep rates as low as they originally planned. 😬

More in   Policy

View All

Risks To The Rate Cut Thesis

One of the big themes we’ve discussed for the last four months has been the Fed cutting rates in 2024. However, there’s been a major disconnect between the market’s expectations and the Fed’s guidance since November. That disconnect made today’s Fed decision and commentary tricky for the market to digest. Let’s talk about why. 🤔

First off, going into this year, the Fed fund futures market was anticipating six rate cuts during 2024. Meanwhile, the Fed’s guidance in December suggested the central bank was estimating just three cuts during the year, as it believes there are still upside risks to inflation.

Read It

Bears Lurk As Bankers Hike

The Federal Reserve’s 25 bp hike is getting all the attention this week, but several other central banks recently made policy decisions worth noting. 📝

The European Central Bank (ECB) raised rates by 50 bps to 3.00%;
The Swiss National Bank raised rates by 50 bps to 1.50%;
The Bank of England raised rates by 25 bps to 4.25%;
The Bank of Canada held rates at 4.50%;
The Bank of Japan held rates at -0.1%; and
Banco Central do Brasil held rates at 13.75%.

Read It

A Unanimous Decision

After a hectic few weeks in the banking sector, most of the market expected a 25 bp rate hike at today’s meeting. And that’s what the Fed delivered. 👍

Let’s start with the redlined version of the FOMC’s statement from Nick Timiraos: 

Read It