SOFI Shares Slip After Muddy Waters Takes Short Position — What’s The Rationale?

• Muddy Waters alleged that SOFI’s charge-off data seemingly contains a mathematical impossible. 
• The short seller also alleged that SOFI uses ‘manipulative’ financial modeling techniques, on its $12.9 billion student loan portfolio that generates approximately $450 million per year in Day 1 Fair Value gains. 
• The report said there is possibility that there are more extensive misstatements that the short seller have not detected. 

Short seller Muddy Waters Research on Tuesday revealed a short position on SoFi Technologies (SOFI) shares and alleged that the financial technology firm had a material misstatement of at least $312 million of unrecorded debt. 

Shares closed 1.5% lower on Tuesday. 

“If we are correct, it raises the possibility that there are more extensive misstatements we have not detected,” Muddy Waters said in its report. 

“SOFI is a financial engineering treadmill, not a healthily growing origination business. SOFI shareholders are incessantly diluted so management can hit bonus targets through GE Capital-style loan marks and Enron-esque off-balance-sheet structures that disguise borrowings as revenue,” it added. 

“Per our estimates, and excluding external financings, it is increasingly likely Anthony Noto would lose substantially all of his $10+ million PSU performance bonus if not for the intellectually dishonest and misleading financial reporting we have outlined in this report,” Muddy Waters said. 

Off-Balance-Sheet Parking

Muddy Waters alleged that SOFI’s charge-off data seemingly contained a mathematical impossibility that strongly implies loans are being charged off outside SOFI’s reported metrics. 

“The only explanation of which we can conceive is that SOFI is parking defaulted loans off balance sheet before charge offs,” the report said. 

SOFI’s Response

SOFI responded to the short seller report, saying that it intends to explore potential legal action against Muddy Waters for the factually inaccurate and misleading report.

“The claims made in the Muddy Waters report demonstrate a fundamental lack of understanding of our financial statements and business,” the company said. “SoFi maintains strong confidence in the integrity of our financial reporting,”.  

Retail Reaction

Retail sentiment around SOFI stock trended in the ‘bullish’ territory amid ‘high’ message volume. 

Shares in the company have fallen 35% so far in 2026. 

For updates and corrections, email newsroom[at]stocktwits[dot]com.