What’s Hurting BJ Stock? Wall Street Points To Gas Costs, Margin Squeeze, Weak Consumer

• Citi cut its BJ’s price target to $100 from $118, citing weaker merchandise margins and lower valuations in the retail sector.
• BofA cut its BJ’s price target to $100 from $110, saying near-term challenges could limit earnings growth despite strong Q1 results. 
• BJ’s CEO Robert Eddy said higher gas prices squeezed household budgets, especially for lower-income shoppers.

BJ's Wholesale Club Holdings (BJ) faced scrutiny from Wall Street after two firms lowered their price targets on the warehouse retailer following its fiscal first-quarter (Q1) earnings report on Friday. 

BJ's Wholesale Club stock tumbled 8.3% on Friday, its worst day in nine months, after investors aggressively sold shares even as the company’s Q1 earnings beat Street estimates. 

Margin Pressure And Rising Costs Cloud BJ’s Outlook 

Analysts and investors ignored the headline numbers and instead focused on weaker underlying trends tied to merchandise demand, margin pressure and unchanged annual guidance.  

Citi reduced its price target on BJ’s to $100 from $118 while maintaining a ‘Buy’ rating on the stock. Analysts cited weaker merchandise margin trends during the quarter and declining valuation multiples across the retail sector.

However, the new price target still implied a 15% upside potential to the stock’s closing price on Friday.

Bank of America also lowered its price target on BJ’s shares, trimming it to $100 from $110 while keeping a ‘Neutral’ rating. The firm acknowledged that BJ’s exceeded quarterly expectations through stronger sales and disciplined expense management, but warned that several near-term challenges could limit future earnings upgrades.

Analysts were concerned about weaker merchandise profits during the quarter. Retailers are still dealing with high shipping and supply chain costs, while heavy discounting and competitive pricing are putting more pressure on profit margins.

Rising Gas Prices Add Pressure On BJ’s Shoppers 

In the Q1 earnings call, BJ's Wholesale Club Chairman and CEO Robert Eddy said gas prices rose sharply during the quarter, making it harder for customers to manage household expenses. 

“Gas prices remain elevated, and that pressure is real for families. To put this in further context, in April alone, our members spent $143 million more at our pumps than they did a year ago. That's equivalent to approximately 3.5% in merchandise comp dollars,” said Eddy. 

Eddy added that lower-income households are feeling greater financial pressure as rising costs continue to strain their budgets.

BJ's Q1 net profit fell to $142.7 million from $149.8 million last year. The merchandise gross margin, excluding fuel sales and membership fee revenue, declined by roughly 10 basis points. 

What BJ’s Retail Traders Are Saying 

On Stocktwits, retail sentiment around the stock shifted from ‘extremely bullish’ to ‘bullish’ the previous day. 

A user said, “Will be interesting to see what happens to those who shorted this stock on Friday. I’m not confident it will go in the direction the bears are hoping for.”

Another user said, “Earnings report wasn’t that bad, stock oversold. started a long position.”

BJ stock has declined nearly 4% year-to-date. 

Also See: Adam Back Warns Memecoins Are Going To Zero Amid ‘Hyperbitcoinization’ — Dogecoin Rallies Higher

For updates and corrections, email newsroom[at]stocktwits[dot]com.