PZZA Stock Jumps Overnight: Analyst Remains Bullish Despite Acquisition Drama, Sales Pressure

• Stephens maintained its ‘Overweight’ rating on Papa John’s with a $40 price target.
• The firm expects near-term caution due to weak traffic but sees long-term margin improvement.
• Papa John’s franchisee Nadeem Bajwa has joined Irth Capital’s $1.5 billion bid to take the company private.   

Papa John's International (PZZA) stock surged nearly 8% after hours on Thursday and continued its ascent overnight as the company became the focus of takeover speculation after a major franchise operator jumped in with a private equity-backed bid to acquire the struggling pizza chain.

Following the takeover report, analysts at Stephens reiterated their positive stance on the pizza chain even as the business faces slowing customer traffic, softer comparable sales and operational adjustments.

Stephens Maintains Positive Outlook On PZZA

According to a Reuters report, Nadeem Bajwa, the company’s largest domestic franchisee, has teamed with Irth Capital Management in support of the latter’s proposed $47 per share transaction to take Papa John’s private. The offer represents a 44% premium to Papa John’s Thursday’s closing price. 

Stephens said the latest development adds another layer to the company’s long-running acquisition narrative, which analysts say has helped support valuation levels despite operational headwinds.

The firm kept its “Overweight” rating on Papa John’s shares, with a $40 price target, implying a 22% upside from the stock’s last close.

Stephens added that investor sentiment may remain cautious in the short term as the company works through declining customer visits and planned menu change initiatives. However, the firm believes the company still has a viable path toward improving profitability over time through refranchising efforts, supply-chain efficiencies and tighter cost controls.

PZZA Battles Weak Demand, Slow Sales 

In early May, the company reported weaker first-quarter (Q1) results as slowing demand in North America weighed on revenue, earnings and comparable sales. 

The pizza chain said softer consumer spending and reduced transaction volumes in its domestic business offset gains from international operations. Global system-wide restaurant sales reached approximately $1.2 billion during the quarter, reflecting a 3% decline from last year. Comparable sales in North America dropped 6.4%. Revenue fell 7.7% year over year to $478.6 million.

Papa John's sees global system-wide sales ranging from flat to slightly lower for 2026.

PZZA Retail Traders View 

On Stocktwits, retail sentiment around the stock turned to ‘extremely bullish’ from ‘bullish’ territory the previous day. 

A user said, “Things heating up in the sector. $PZZA and $WEN both will go private. Load.”

Another user said, “THIS TIME BUYOUT IS REAL.” 

PZZA stock has declined nearly 15% year-to-date. 

Also See: GEMI Stock Soars After Hours As Stronger-Than-Expected Q1 Results Meet $100M Winklevoss Investment

For updates and corrections, email newsroom[at]stocktwits[dot]com.